On August 25, 2018 one man was murdered in Chemnitz and two others were injured.
According to the police the three victims were attacked without any need for self-defense.
[1]
[2]
It is being investigated against three asylum seekers Farhad A., Alaa S. and Yousif A. from Iraq.
Farhad A. is a criminal convicted of theft, drug trafficking and assault.
[3]
In addition Farhad A. was supposed to leave and should have been deported.
[4]
Yousif A. presented fake documents and Alaa S. was recognized unchecked as a refugee.
[5]
Several days after the murder there were demonstrations and the federal government spoke of manhunts on foreigners and gatherings (Zusammenrottungen) that were not to be tolerated.
[6]
The demonstration were legal regardless of the public opinion.
But the murder on August 25, was only the tip of the iceberg. Of the 247,422 people with their primary residence in Chemnitz only 18,721 (7.6 %) were non-German nationals as of December 31, 2017. [8] In Chemnitz in 2017 from 618 suspects for violent crimes 281 (45.5 %) were non-German citizens. [7,R13995] Thus non-German nationals are overrepresented by a factor of 6. The number of acts of violence among right-wing extremist criminals in Chemnitz was 6 in 2017. [9,S.106] And the accusation of rioting by the federal government should have fueled the mood even more. The word Zusammenrottung was used in the constitution of the East-German-State to ban demonstrations. The citizens of the former East-German-State are therefore confronted with old prohibitions almost 30 years after the reunification. Statistically speaking there is little that can be blamed on the Chemnitzers.
On December 3, the Center for Political Beauty (Zentrum für politische Schönheit/ZPS) published the project Soko Chemnitz. The goal was to identify those who demonstrated in Chemnitz after the murder of Daniel H. and to report them to their employers. The goal was to make the suspects lose their jobs. The ZPS demanded directly to denounce colleagues, neighbors and acquaintances. [11] [12] The ZPS justifies its actions by saying that criticism of immigration is illegitimate and that the AfD is undemocratic. Unspoken it is assumed that the demonstrators are voters of the AfD. Thus the ZPS builds up an oversized straw man to justify his own deeds. [13]
But in Germany the right of assembly still applies. [7] The dissemination of false facts against better knowledge in relation to another person fulfills the offense of slander. [4] And the call for denunciations fulfills the offense of the public call for criminal offenses. [15] Therefore the actions of the ZPS are clearly illegal.
However a media scandal did not took place. The mainstrem media have mentioned the events completely uncritically or even praised them. The newspapers taz and Tagesspiegel wrote that the actions were morally justified. For this they also use the straw man that all demonstrators are Nazis and dangerous. [16] [17] The public broadcaster MDR even assumes that the demonstrators have broken the law. However they do not provide any evidence. [18] Dangerous and inhumane however were only the ZPS and those from the left who defended the ZPS for their actions.
On December 5, the site was shut down and the ZPS announced that the project Soko Chemnitz served as a honeypot. The search function of the website was used to collect and evaluate the input data. [19] [20] [21] The ZPS therefore assumes that the affected persons have searched themselves on the website. But it is not guaranteed that people search for themselves nor it is guaranteed that people looking for themselves were there. Therefore the honeypot itself could be the honeypot. Those who now go against the ZPS with legal means deliver the ZPS their own data. Thus the ZPS could also get the personal data of the demonstrators. Meanwhile the taz did not refrained from praising this step as well. [22]
One thing should be clear, if there is any doubt left. No neither the Gestapo nor the Stasi were an artistic action without any relation to reality. Unfortunately everything was real. The second manhunt which took place in Chemnitz was directed against dissenting citizens.
[1] Faktencheck zu Chemnitzer Todesfall: Täter handelten nicht in Notwehr 2018-08-28:
http://www.lvz.de/Region/Polizeiticker/Chemnitz-Polizei-dementiert-Geruechte-ueber-zweites-Todesopfer
[2] Tatverdächtige der Messerattacke in Chemnitz beantragen Haftprüfung 2018-09-14:
https://www.mdr.de/sachsen/chemnitz/chemnitz-stollberg/inhaftierter-chemnitz-tatbeteiligung-messerattacke-100.html
[3] Dritter Verdächtiger weiterhin flüchtig 2018-09-07:
https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/verdaechtiger-weiterhin-fluechtig-nach-toedlicher-messerattacke-in-chemnitz-farhad-a-haette-abgeschoben-werden-muessen_id_9553205.html
[4] Dritter Tatverdächtiger von Chemnitz: Klage gegen Abschiebung 2018-09-13:
http://www.lvz.de/Region/Polizeiticker/Dritter-Tatverdaechtiger-von-Chemnitz-Klage-gegen-Abschiebung
[5] Tatverdächtige in Chemnitz – Dokumentation des Versagens 2018-09-04:
https://www.abendblatt.de/politik/article215255213/Tatverdaechtige-in-Chemnitz-Dokumentation-des-Versagens.html
[6] Der schwarze Sonntag von Chemnitz: Messerstecherei, Hetzjagd, Kontrollverlust 2018-08-28:
https://www.nzz.ch/international/chemnitz-messerstecherei-hetzjagd-kontrollverlust-ld.1415023
[7] Grundgesetz Art. 8:
https://dejure.org/gesetze/GG/8.html
[8] Bevölkerung der Stadt wächst auch im Jahr 2017 2018-01-23:
https://www.chemnitz.de/chemnitz/de/aktuell/presse/pressemitteilungen/2018/49.html
[9] Grundtabelle - Kreise - ausgewählte Straftaten/-gruppen 2018-05-08:
https://www.bka.de/DE/AktuelleInformationen/StatistikenLagebilder/PolizeilicheKriminalstatistik/PKS2017/BKATabellen/bkaTabellenLaenderKreiseStaedteFaelle.html;jsessionid=6CE67EE745DA2CCBE1578BC547EF6EDA.live2292?nn=96600
[10] Sächsischer Verfassungsschutzbericht 2017:
http://www.verfassungsschutz.sachsen.de/download/VSB2017_webversion.pdf
[11] Online-Pranger zum Mitmachen 2018-12-03:
https://www.sueddeutsche.de/kultur/zentrum-politische-schoenheit-chemnitz-1.4237167
[12] Heftiger Streit um Online-Pranger 2018-12-04:
http://www.taz.de/Zentrum-fuer-Politische-Schoenheit/!5556526/
[13] Wo der Staat versagt, muss die Zivilgesellschaft ran 2018-12-04:
http://www.fr.de/kultur/soko-chemnitz-wo-der-staat-versagt-muss-die-zivilgesellschaft-ran-a-1632626,0#artpager-1632626-1
[14] Strafgesetzbuch Art 187:
https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__187.html
[15] Strafgesetzbuch Art 111:
https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__111.html
[16] Neue Aktion von Politische Schönheit - Wanted: Nazis! 2018-12-03:
http://www.taz.de/Neue-Aktion-von-Politische-Schoenheit/!5555146/
[17] "Darf man das?" - ist die falsche Frage 2018-12-05:
https://www.tagesspiegel.de/kultur/zentrum-fuer-politische-schoenheit-darf-man-das-ist-die-falsche-frage/23712606.html
[18] Nicht die Aktion spaltet die Gesellschaft, sondern kriminelles Verhalten von Mitbürgern 2018-12-04:
https://www.mdr.de/sachsen/chemnitz/chemnitz-stollberg/interview-zps-kunstaktion-soko-chemnitz-100.html
[19] Erklärung des Zentrums für Politische Schönheit - "Soko Chemnitz" soll Falle für Rechtsextreme gewesen sein 2018-12-06:
http://www.spiegel.de/kultur/gesellschaft/zentrum-fuer-politische-schoenheit-soko-chemnitz-soll-falle-fuer-rechtsextreme-gewesen-sein-a-1242183.html
[20] Danke, liebe Nazis - Rechte geben freiwillig ihre Namen und ihr persönliches Netzwerk preis. Die Soko Chemnitz bedankt sich. 2018-12-05:
http://www.fr.de/politik/rechtsextremismus/soko-chemnitz-danke-liebe-nazis-a-1633449
[21] Der Rechtsdrift ist massiv, abgestimmt und stetig voranschreitend 2018-12-06:
https://www.heise.de/tp/features/Der-Rechtsdrift-ist-massiv-abgestimmt-und-stetig-voranschreitend-4242780.html?wt_mc=rss.tp.beitrag.atom
[22] Schon die Kontroverse ist ein Erfolg 2018-12-06:
http://www.taz.de/Antifa-Kunstaktion-Soko-Chemnitz/!5557196/
The demonstration were legal regardless of the public opinion.
"All Germans have the right to assemble peacefully and without weapons without registration or permission"The freedom of assembly is still a fundamental right for Germany.
Grundgesetz Art. 8 [7]
But the murder on August 25, was only the tip of the iceberg. Of the 247,422 people with their primary residence in Chemnitz only 18,721 (7.6 %) were non-German nationals as of December 31, 2017. [8] In Chemnitz in 2017 from 618 suspects for violent crimes 281 (45.5 %) were non-German citizens. [7,R13995] Thus non-German nationals are overrepresented by a factor of 6. The number of acts of violence among right-wing extremist criminals in Chemnitz was 6 in 2017. [9,S.106] And the accusation of rioting by the federal government should have fueled the mood even more. The word Zusammenrottung was used in the constitution of the East-German-State to ban demonstrations. The citizens of the former East-German-State are therefore confronted with old prohibitions almost 30 years after the reunification. Statistically speaking there is little that can be blamed on the Chemnitzers.
On December 3, the Center for Political Beauty (Zentrum für politische Schönheit/ZPS) published the project Soko Chemnitz. The goal was to identify those who demonstrated in Chemnitz after the murder of Daniel H. and to report them to their employers. The goal was to make the suspects lose their jobs. The ZPS demanded directly to denounce colleagues, neighbors and acquaintances. [11] [12] The ZPS justifies its actions by saying that criticism of immigration is illegitimate and that the AfD is undemocratic. Unspoken it is assumed that the demonstrators are voters of the AfD. Thus the ZPS builds up an oversized straw man to justify his own deeds. [13]
But in Germany the right of assembly still applies. [7] The dissemination of false facts against better knowledge in relation to another person fulfills the offense of slander. [4] And the call for denunciations fulfills the offense of the public call for criminal offenses. [15] Therefore the actions of the ZPS are clearly illegal.
However a media scandal did not took place. The mainstrem media have mentioned the events completely uncritically or even praised them. The newspapers taz and Tagesspiegel wrote that the actions were morally justified. For this they also use the straw man that all demonstrators are Nazis and dangerous. [16] [17] The public broadcaster MDR even assumes that the demonstrators have broken the law. However they do not provide any evidence. [18] Dangerous and inhumane however were only the ZPS and those from the left who defended the ZPS for their actions.
On December 5, the site was shut down and the ZPS announced that the project Soko Chemnitz served as a honeypot. The search function of the website was used to collect and evaluate the input data. [19] [20] [21] The ZPS therefore assumes that the affected persons have searched themselves on the website. But it is not guaranteed that people search for themselves nor it is guaranteed that people looking for themselves were there. Therefore the honeypot itself could be the honeypot. Those who now go against the ZPS with legal means deliver the ZPS their own data. Thus the ZPS could also get the personal data of the demonstrators. Meanwhile the taz did not refrained from praising this step as well. [22]
One thing should be clear, if there is any doubt left. No neither the Gestapo nor the Stasi were an artistic action without any relation to reality. Unfortunately everything was real. The second manhunt which took place in Chemnitz was directed against dissenting citizens.
[1] Faktencheck zu Chemnitzer Todesfall: Täter handelten nicht in Notwehr 2018-08-28:
http://www.lvz.de/Region/Polizeiticker/Chemnitz-Polizei-dementiert-Geruechte-ueber-zweites-Todesopfer
[2] Tatverdächtige der Messerattacke in Chemnitz beantragen Haftprüfung 2018-09-14:
https://www.mdr.de/sachsen/chemnitz/chemnitz-stollberg/inhaftierter-chemnitz-tatbeteiligung-messerattacke-100.html
[3] Dritter Verdächtiger weiterhin flüchtig 2018-09-07:
https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/verdaechtiger-weiterhin-fluechtig-nach-toedlicher-messerattacke-in-chemnitz-farhad-a-haette-abgeschoben-werden-muessen_id_9553205.html
[4] Dritter Tatverdächtiger von Chemnitz: Klage gegen Abschiebung 2018-09-13:
http://www.lvz.de/Region/Polizeiticker/Dritter-Tatverdaechtiger-von-Chemnitz-Klage-gegen-Abschiebung
[5] Tatverdächtige in Chemnitz – Dokumentation des Versagens 2018-09-04:
https://www.abendblatt.de/politik/article215255213/Tatverdaechtige-in-Chemnitz-Dokumentation-des-Versagens.html
[6] Der schwarze Sonntag von Chemnitz: Messerstecherei, Hetzjagd, Kontrollverlust 2018-08-28:
https://www.nzz.ch/international/chemnitz-messerstecherei-hetzjagd-kontrollverlust-ld.1415023
[7] Grundgesetz Art. 8:
https://dejure.org/gesetze/GG/8.html
[8] Bevölkerung der Stadt wächst auch im Jahr 2017 2018-01-23:
https://www.chemnitz.de/chemnitz/de/aktuell/presse/pressemitteilungen/2018/49.html
[9] Grundtabelle - Kreise - ausgewählte Straftaten/-gruppen 2018-05-08:
https://www.bka.de/DE/AktuelleInformationen/StatistikenLagebilder/PolizeilicheKriminalstatistik/PKS2017/BKATabellen/bkaTabellenLaenderKreiseStaedteFaelle.html;jsessionid=6CE67EE745DA2CCBE1578BC547EF6EDA.live2292?nn=96600
[10] Sächsischer Verfassungsschutzbericht 2017:
http://www.verfassungsschutz.sachsen.de/download/VSB2017_webversion.pdf
[11] Online-Pranger zum Mitmachen 2018-12-03:
https://www.sueddeutsche.de/kultur/zentrum-politische-schoenheit-chemnitz-1.4237167
[12] Heftiger Streit um Online-Pranger 2018-12-04:
http://www.taz.de/Zentrum-fuer-Politische-Schoenheit/!5556526/
[13] Wo der Staat versagt, muss die Zivilgesellschaft ran 2018-12-04:
http://www.fr.de/kultur/soko-chemnitz-wo-der-staat-versagt-muss-die-zivilgesellschaft-ran-a-1632626,0#artpager-1632626-1
[14] Strafgesetzbuch Art 187:
https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__187.html
[15] Strafgesetzbuch Art 111:
https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__111.html
[16] Neue Aktion von Politische Schönheit - Wanted: Nazis! 2018-12-03:
http://www.taz.de/Neue-Aktion-von-Politische-Schoenheit/!5555146/
[17] "Darf man das?" - ist die falsche Frage 2018-12-05:
https://www.tagesspiegel.de/kultur/zentrum-fuer-politische-schoenheit-darf-man-das-ist-die-falsche-frage/23712606.html
[18] Nicht die Aktion spaltet die Gesellschaft, sondern kriminelles Verhalten von Mitbürgern 2018-12-04:
https://www.mdr.de/sachsen/chemnitz/chemnitz-stollberg/interview-zps-kunstaktion-soko-chemnitz-100.html
[19] Erklärung des Zentrums für Politische Schönheit - "Soko Chemnitz" soll Falle für Rechtsextreme gewesen sein 2018-12-06:
http://www.spiegel.de/kultur/gesellschaft/zentrum-fuer-politische-schoenheit-soko-chemnitz-soll-falle-fuer-rechtsextreme-gewesen-sein-a-1242183.html
[20] Danke, liebe Nazis - Rechte geben freiwillig ihre Namen und ihr persönliches Netzwerk preis. Die Soko Chemnitz bedankt sich. 2018-12-05:
http://www.fr.de/politik/rechtsextremismus/soko-chemnitz-danke-liebe-nazis-a-1633449
[21] Der Rechtsdrift ist massiv, abgestimmt und stetig voranschreitend 2018-12-06:
https://www.heise.de/tp/features/Der-Rechtsdrift-ist-massiv-abgestimmt-und-stetig-voranschreitend-4242780.html?wt_mc=rss.tp.beitrag.atom
[22] Schon die Kontroverse ist ein Erfolg 2018-12-06:
http://www.taz.de/Antifa-Kunstaktion-Soko-Chemnitz/!5557196/
Kommentare
Kommentar veröffentlichen